The Sorting of Luna Lovegood

I love that I can share my love of Harry Potter with my mom, but she’s never read the books, and sometimes, she gets things so, so wrong. Like the other day, when she said that Luna Lovegood should be a Hufflepuff. I’m sorry, mom, but no; the sorting hat was definitely right about Luna, although I can see how someone who has only seen the movies might think otherwise. So today, I’m going to talk about Luna and why I’m convinced she really is a Ravenclaw.

First of all, Rowena Ravenclaw has been described as “wise”, valued “wit and learning”, and preferred students with “a ready mind”. I’ll admit that doesn’t sound much like Luna at first glance. She’s eccentric, weird, and prone to believing all sorts of nonsensical things. But what most defines Luna is her wide-open mind and unstoppable hunger to know things.

She believes all kinds of nonsense, but she’s often right when everyone else is wrong. She’s one of the few who believes Harry when he says that Voldemort has returned, and she also believes that Sirius Black is innocent, although she’s under the impression that he’s secretly musical sensation Stubby Boardman. She’s right not to believe the lies the Daily Prophet prints, and her father’s magazine, while wrong about the existence of nargles and crumple-horned snorkacks, provides a voice of truth in contrast to the Prophet’s polished lies. In the final book, her father introduces Harry, Ron, and Hermione to the Deathly Hallows, which Luna presumably also believes in. The Deathly Hallows prove critical to the plot and enable Harry to defeat Voldemort. And, finally, she is the only one who realizes Helena Ravenclaw’s ghost might be able to help them find the lost diadem. If no one alive has seen it, they need to talk to someone who is dead, but although there are ghosts at Hogwarts, it still takes a creative mind to come to that conclusion.

You might say that a stopped clock is right twice a day. But I would also say that it’s through exploring every possibility that one finds the right answer. In the creative process, that’s called brainstorming. In the world of Harry Potter, it’s called reading The Quibbler.

Luna wants to know everything. She’s not a stereotypical nerd, but she’s curious about everything from magical creatures to divination to her father’s conspiracy theories, and she seems to soak in new knowledge (or misinformation) like a sponge. She has a sharp mind in the sense that – at least in the books – she is not just the weird girl who believes in nargles for no reason. She seems to thoroughly understand the creatures and ideas she believes in. She’s wrong, for example, about the rotfang conspiracy, which claims that the aurors are planning to take over the Ministry of Magic using dark magic and … gum disease? But she understands the theory well enough to talk about it endlessly at Slughorn’s Christmas party, and she’s definitely right that there’s corruption in the Ministry.

She’s also smart enough to know when she’s being lied to. I think the only reason she believes all that nonsense is because her father and the other people who write for The Quibbler honestly believe it; the moment the Ministry starts spreading its propaganda, she figures it out and cheerfully ignores it.

Another thing I want to mention is that – while we don’t see her in class, since she’s a year younger than Harry – she seems concerned with the quality of her education. Along with joining Dumbledore’s Army, which started out as a way of learning what Umbridge refused to teach them, she is also the one of the few positive characters to ever criticize Hagrid. She claims he “isn’t a very good teacher”, while the main trio also realize this but stand by him resolutely because he’s their friend. Being more interested in whether a teacher teaches well than whether he’s likable seems like a Ravenclaw sort of attitude, and one that, to be perfectly honest, I can see myself taking if I were in Hagrid’s class.

After leaving Hogwarts, Luna goes on to become a magizoologist. In order to have a real career in that field, she would presumably have to come to terms with the fact that most of her fantasy creatures just don’t exist (although I like to think she eventually discovers one or two of them, because like I said before, she is wrong so often that people don’t notice how often she’s also right).

Basically, what I’m trying to say is that Luna’s whole world is made up of thoughts and ideas, some of them right some of them laughably mistaken. And while she does process things a little differently, she’s much more intelligent and perceptive than other people give her credit for. Ravenclaws don’t have to be studious and logical; in fact, according to Pottermore, many are individual and even eccentric, although Luna takes that to an extreme. What defines Ravenclaw most, I think, is their love of knowledge and sharp minds, and while that looks different in Luna than in someone like Hermione, it’s still very much there.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s